Tuesday, 8 September 2026

Enough of this Misguided Current Emphasis on Practical Skills over Theory

We now very frequently hear about “market-driven courses”. According to this outlook, subjects such as history, literature and philosophy are a mighty waste of time because the “market” does not need them. Yet if life is only about getting jobs, then we are cogs in the capitalist machine, and cogs do not need to think. Indeed, one capitalist is said to have declared that there is no need for critical thinkers, but only for workers!

 

In line with the emphasis on “practical subjects”, we are now told that the writing of dissertations/theses at university is a waste of time because many people do not get to read them, and that most of them are of very little practical benefit. However, this piece of advice, impressive as it may sound, is based on the assumption that anything we learn in school or university must be of immediate practical use. If that were true, many of the things we enjoy today may never have been invented because the ideas behind some of them took centuries, even millennia, before they were put to practical use. Here are a few:

  • Democritus and Leucippus spoke about atoms in ancient Greece, but atomic energy was only exploited in the twentieth century.
  • Aristotle wrote a lot about logic, and from the nineteenth century, more than two thousand years later, that knowledge was converted into computer science.
  • Even the ancient Greek myth of two brothers, Daedilus and Icarus, who made for themselves wings and flew, was actualized more than two millennia later with the invention of the aircraft by the two Wright Brothers (Wilbur and Orville).

 

So if I was one of the little boys in William Golding’s *Lord of the Flies*, I would have said “sucks to the emphasis on practice above theory!”  

No comments:

Post a Comment